Co-processing refers to the simultaneous treatment of biogenic feedstocks and fossil-derived feedstocks in refinery process units to produce blended fossil and renewable fuel products. Under the B.C Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS), the fossil portion of co-processed fuel is considered a base fuel and cannot earn positive compliance units or count toward renewable fuel supply requirements. Conversely, the renewable portion contributes to renewable supply requirements and is eligible to earn positive compliance units.
The renewable portion of co-processed fuel is physically indistinguishable from the fossil portion. This creates unique challenges in both quantifying the renewable volume within co-processed fuels, and in determining the Carbon Intensity (CI) of the renewable component.
This document provides guidance on how to determine the renewable fraction of co-processed fuel and outlines acceptable methods for determining the inputs required to model the renewable fuel’s CI. This document applies only to co processing that occurs in a refinery. Although other co-processing methods exist, they are not covered by this methodology. For more information, please contact the Low Carbon Fuels Branch (LCFB) at lcfs@gov.bc.ca.
This document focuses specifically on methodologies and requirements for co processed fuels. It does not provide general guidance on CI application procedures or modelling and should be used in conjunction with the guidance provided in RLCF-008: Carbon Intensity Applications and the applicable – pathway specific – GHGenius user guides available on the Renewable and low carbon fuel resources page.
Operating data attained when the refinery is producing fuel using 100% fossil-derived feedstock.
Operating data attained when the refinery is co-processing with fossil and biogenic feedstocks. This data is used to determine the CI of the renewable portion of co-processed fuel. During the Benchmarking Period, operating conditions are representative of regular co-processing operations, and the renewable feedstock feed rate is at or above the maximum feed rate that will occur when fuel is produced for compliance reporting.
A period of 7+ days during which benchmark data is gathered.
Fuel produced through simultaneous processing of biogenic and fossil-derived feedstocks in a refinery, resulting in a fuel that has fossil and renewable content.
A secondary product that is produced alongside the primary product during the refining process. Examples: naphtha, fuel gas, sponge gas, LPG, etc.
Carbon-14 testing via accelerator mass spectrometry (ASTM D6866 - Method B).
Carbon-14 testing via liquid scintillating counting (ASTM D6866 - Method C).
Fuel producers must apply for a unique CI if variations in operating conditions have a significant impact (defined below) on the CI of a fuel. The set of operating parameters associated with a CI is referred to as the operating mode. For example, if seasonal variation in operating parameters causes a significant impact to the CI, the fuel producer must obtain CIs for both the winter and summer operating modes.
Any input or output that impacts the co-processed fuel’s CI calculation by more than the greater of:
This section outlines data collection and testing requirements. The data gathered is used to inform allocation methodologies for CI determination, and to determine the biogenic content of the co-processed fuel for compliance reporting. Note that raw data does not need to be included with the Technical Report that accompanies the CI Application. The Technical Report must state how the requirements in this section are met, outline how modelling inputs were determined and, where relevant, provide supporting summarized or consolidated data tables.
The LCFS allows fuel producers to apply for either 1-year or 3-year fuel codes depending on their stage of development and the availability of operational data. Where applicable the 1-year vs. 3-year requirements are outlined in each section.
Data collection and testing requirements for 3-year fuel codes are intended to align with the Canadian Government’s Clean Fuel Regulations (CFR) such that data collected for CFR benchmarking scenarios and annual credit creation may be used for LCFS CI applications and compliance reporting.
Baseline data (operating data attained when the refinery is producing fuel using 100% fossil-derived feedstock) is used as a reference to determine the allocation of hydrogen, energy and chemical inputs to the biogenic fuel portion. A minimum of 7 consecutive days of baseline data covering each operating mode is required.
The following baseline data collection requirements apply to both 1-year and 3 year fuel codes:
The following baseline data is required for each operating mode and must be included with the Technical Report accompanying the CI Application:
Applicants seeking a 1-year fuel code can select one of the following options to determine the CI modelling inputs. Where trial run or benchmark data is used, it must be gathered within 3 years of the CI application date. The following benchmark data is required, and must be included in the Technical Report accompanying the CI Application:
1. Trial Run Data
2. Design Data
3. Benchmark Data, as outlined below for 3-year fuel codes
To be eligible for a 3-year fuel code, applicants must have been co-processing for 12 or more months and must collect a minimum of 7 consecutive days of benchmark data for each operating mode and renewable feedstock. Benchmark data must be gathered within 3 years of the CI application date.
During the benchmarking period, applicants must ensure that operating conditions are representative and that the renewable feedstock feed rate is at or above the maximum feed rate that will occur when fuel is produced for compliance reporting. The following benchmark data is required, and must be included in the Technical Report accompanying the CI Application:
Whenever possible, benchmark data should be gathered using a single biogenic feedstock. In facilities that cannot maintain separation of biogenic feedstocks (i.e. facilities that have a single biogenic feedstock supply tank for multiple feedstocks), separate benchmarking runs may be completed at the highest achievable concentrations of each feedstock type. For example, if a facility co-produces renewable diesel using both canola oil and tallow feedstocks, they should complete the following benchmarking runs:
The Ministry will consider applications where benchmark data is gathered from mixed biogenic feedstock co-processing (at any ratio) if the following conditions are met:
Carbon-14 (C-14) testing is used to determine the amount of renewable carbon present in a co-processed fuel or co-product. Under the LCFS, C-14 testing is required to determine the fraction of renewable fuel in co-processed fuels as well as the fraction of co-products attributable to the renewable fuel volume. For co products with renewable content, C-14 testing is required only when the coproduct has a significant impact on the CI of the renewable fuel.
This data is required for compliance reporting and CI calculations. Information supporting CI calculations must be included with the Technical Report accompanying the CI Application. Information for compliance reporting must be retained and made available upon request.
All samples must be obtained immediately downstream from the co-processing unit or from the final holding tank of the co-processed fuel.
Liquid fuels and co-products:
Option 1: One representative Method B sample per operating mode gathered during representative co-processing
Option 2: Design data with rationale for why C-14 testing was not possible prior to applying for a fuel code
Gaseous fuels and co-products (excluding steam):
Liquid fuels and co-products:
Gaseous fuels and co-products:
Alternate methods of demonstrating the biogenic content of gaseous fuels and co-products may be used if rationale supporting their accuracy is provided.
Liquid fuels:
Gaseous fuels:
Alternate methods of demonstrating the biogenic content of gaseous fuels and co-products may be used if rationale supporting their accuracy is provided.
These requirements apply to flowmeters that inform both CI modelling and compliance reporting. Flowmeter specifications and locations must be outlined in the Technical Report accompanying the CI Application.
Fuels and co-products:
Fuels:
Co-products:
This section outlines acceptable methods of allocating inputs to the biogenic portion of the co-processed fuel. Allocation is required to determine appropriate inputs for CI modelling.
Hydrogen allocation is determined based on daily average hydrogen consumption data gathered during the benchmarking period, with reference to the baseline data.
Applicants must provide the daily average hydrogen consumption in the benchmark data and baseline data, explain how allocation is calculated based on this data, and explain how the input value for GHGenius was determined. Where trial run or design data is used for 1-year fuel codes, applicants must justify how they determined the hydrogen input value for GHGenius. This information must be provided in the Technical Report that accompanies the CI application.
Chemical and energy input allocation is determined based on daily average input data gathered during the benchmarking period, with reference to the baseline data.
For all energy and chemical inputs with a significant impact on the CI of the renewable fuel portion, applicants must provide the daily average input data in the benchmark data and baseline data, explain and justify the allocation method they used, and explain how they determined the GHGenius modelling inputs. Where trial run or design data is used for 1-year fuel codes, applicants must justify how they used this data to determine the GHGenius modelling inputs. This information must be provided in the Technical Report that accompanies the CI Application.
The following checklists summarize the requirements for 1-year and 3-year fuel codes. Refer to the Glossary and links for detailed requirements, and to RLCF-008 How to Complete a Carbon Intensity Application for general guidance on completing CI Applications.
| Category | Requirements |
|---|---|
| Baseline Data |
A minimum of 7 consecutive days of data covering each operating mode collected within three years of the application date. Baseline data collected 3+ years from the application may be accepted if rationale supporting the representativeness of the 3+ year old data is provided. The following baseline data is required for each operating mode:
|
| Benchmark or Alternate Data |
One of the following:
|
| Renewable Content Testing |
Sampling location
Volume determination
CI modelling Liquid fuels and co-products
Gaseous fuels and co-products
|
| Flowmeter Requirements |
One of the following:
|
| Hydrogen Allocation |
One of the following:
|
| Chemical and Energy Input Allocation |
One of the following:
|
| Category | Requirements | |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline Data |
A minimum of 7 consecutive days of data covering each operating mode collected within three years of the application date. Baseline data collected 3+ years from the application may be accepted if rationale supporting the representativeness of the 3+ year old data is provided. The following baseline data is required for each operating mode:
|
|
| Benchmark or Alternate Data |
7 consecutive days of benchmark data for each operating mode including:
|
|
| Renewable Content Testing |
Sampling location Immediately downstream from the co-processing unit or from the final holding tank of the co-processed fuel Volume determination
CI modelling Liquid fuels and co-products
Gaseous fuels and co-products
|
|
| Flowmeter Requirements |
Co-processed fuels
|
Co-products
|
| Hydrogen Allocation |
All of the following:
|
|
| Chemical and Energy Input Allocation |
All of the following:
|
|
This information is for your convenience and guidance only and does not replace or constitute legal advice. It is recommended that parties who may be a fuel supplier review the Low Carbon Fuels Act, Low Carbon Fuels (General) Regulation and the Low Carbon Fuels (Technical) Regulation and seek independent legal advice to confirm their status, legal obligations and opportunities.