Management of the Douglas-Fir Beetle

Decision Framework

This framework describes the decisions and steps — from initial sketch maps to follow-up inspections.

Strategies

These depend on a several factors:

  • infestation size
  • stand susceptibility
  • values
  • access
  • infestation history.

Detection

Ground surveys are the necessary follow-up to aerial surveys and prerequisite to control action. All mapped infestations of three or more infested trees should be ground-checked to verify beetle activity and determine the infestation size.

  • Walkthroughs confirm the previous or suspected identification of beetle and host, collect information to set further survey or management priorities, and estimate population trends.
  • Probes provide more detailed information than walkthroughs and may be appropriate for laying out treatment areas. These systematic strip surveys provide more precise estimates of attack levels, beetle trends and residual stand values. 
  • Star probes may be carried out in trap tree sites or small beetle-kill centres after beetle flight, to ensure no standing attack is undetected and left untreated or unharvested. Attacked trees identified should be harvested or treated.

Damage Symptoms

Adults bore through the bark of Douglas-fir and bore long galleries parallel to the grain of the inner bark to lay their eggs. Reddish boring dust may appear in bark crevices or on the trunk. Adult beetles rarely attack the bottom of the bole, making identification difficult. Wood borers and carpenter ants are commonly active at the base of the tree and their boring dust will appear whitish-red (due to wood sawdust present). Pitch tubes are not formed, but the tree may exude resin from attacks in the upper trunk (”pitch streamers”).

Foliage of killed trees turns from green to light yellow then orange to bright red, usually by the spring of the year following the attack. Colour change can take up to 15 months, which can delay identification of infested trees. Red needles may remain for up to two years after an attack, and aerial spotting of these "redtops" helps to determine the extent of an outbreak.

Damage

Douglas-fir beetles normally infest downed, damaged or stressed trees. As populations increase they will ”mass attack” vigorous trees. Trees die when the flow of nutrients and water between the roots and needles is blocked by feeding larvae and by dead sapwood cells killed by the blue-stain fungi carried by adult Douglas-fir beetles. On the coast, it often takes two years of attack to kill a tree (partial or "strip" attack usually occurs the first year).

Similar Damage by Other Insects

Attacks by secondary bark beetles may produce boring dust in bark crevices.  The flat- and round-headed wood borers (family Buprestidae) often bore bark and wood near the base of Douglas-fir trees. Boring dust will appear creamy-red due to the presence of wood in their boring dust. Carpenter ants also commonly bore at the tree base and will also have whitish boring dust. The Douglas-fir pole beetle is usually found in the smaller diameter trees in the upper portion of the stem. It can be distinguished from the Douglas-fir beetle by its finer boring dust and different gallery patterns. Careful attention to boring dust colour and gallery patterns is necessary to avoid confusing these insects with Douglas-fir beetle.

Treatment

Selection of an appropriate option depends on stand condition, level of infestation, condition of adjacent stands, existence of access, and management objectives for the area. Four main control methods for Douglas-fir beetle are available:

  • sanitation harvesting — maximizes removal of current-attack Douglas-fir to reduce the existing population and inhibit infestation expansion. All trees containing beetles should be harvested and milled before adults emerge in the spring.
  • trap trees — used to reduce overall beetle population levels. Large, healthy Douglas-fir trees are felled into the shade to attract and absorb emerging beetles, then must be removed after the end of beetle flight. The beetles are killed during timber processing.
  • single-tree treatment — similar to those useful for other bark beetles. The Douglas-fir's thick bark makes falling-and-burning and bark peeling very difficult and time consuming, so treatments should be considered only when no other option is available. Treatments include: (1) falling and burning; (2) peeling and burning the bark (seldom used); and (3) single-tree removal.
  • post-logging mop up — necessary after sanitation or other harvesting which creates suitable host material (debris or windthrow). Sanitation harvesting in areas with chronic beetle populations should be followed up with trap trees to absorb residual populations. Areas where logging has been completed should be monitored yearly to locate fresh outbreaks. Falling and burning infested material may destroy beetle progeny if done thoroughly. 

Hazard & risk rating

Hazard rating identifies stands where substantial losses can be expected if an outbreak occurs, and which are highly susceptible to attack. Once all Douglas-fir stands in an area have been rated, resources can be directed to those with the highest hazard, so losses can be minimized. Hazard rating considers stand age, host basal area, stand density, elevation, and other factors.

Stand risk is the probability the Douglas-fir stand will be attacked, based on proximity an infestation. Risk of attack may be determined by comparing survey information on infestations with a forest cover map coded for hazard.

After hazard and risk ratings are completed, management strategies can be developed to minimize beetle losses in priority stands. Danger ratings, or immediate priorities for treatment or management, may be identified by combining hazard and risk.